Docsity
Docsity

Prepare-se para as provas
Prepare-se para as provas

Estude fácil! Tem muito documento disponível na Docsity


Ganhe pontos para baixar
Ganhe pontos para baixar

Ganhe pontos ajudando outros esrudantes ou compre um plano Premium


Guias e Dicas
Guias e Dicas

Microfinance for social change, Resumos de Microfinanças

aulas de direitos humanosda universidade de padova

Tipologia: Resumos

2022

Compartilhado em 03/02/2024

priscila-bianchetti-5
priscila-bianchetti-5 🇮🇹

1 documento

1 / 9

Toggle sidebar

Esta página não é visível na pré-visualização

Não perca as partes importantes!

bg1
15-16/11/2022
The World Bank target for eradicating poverty by 3% is growth in GDP per capita of 4% every year
globally.
GDP is related to a profit (not revenue) generated within a nation. Divided per capita is GDP per capita.
The higher is the GDP growth the lower is the poverty in the country.
In the EU 20 to 25% of people are living at risk of poverty and social exclusion. We do not define the poor
by the number of $ per day, but what the person can afford and what choices and opportunities they have.
In the EU poverty is defined as 17% below the average income in a national level - relative measure.
Absolute measure - in each country Eurostat defines basic needs, if you can not pay it, you are in a
‘severe deprivation”. Roughly 10% of those 25%.
Microfinance is the result of the capitalist system, it’s also a part of it, where GDP defines growth.
Microfinance supports where the capital is needed.
WHY GROWTH IS EVIL?
If we talk about growth and numbers and consumption, we only talk about quantity, we are missing quality.
If we expect non-stop growth due to consumption, we are consuming useless goods, that if we drop the
quality of life might stay the same.
Moreover the consumption based economy is dangerous for the planet.
Solution:
Is there a way to produce GDP without hurting people and the planet?
Kate Rowarth produced a framework. We have to choose among businesses which are in between a
certain threshold related to hr and ecology.
17/11/2021
Billions of dollars are spent into intern.cooperation in Africa for nothing. Over the last years the aid grew
every year, while the GDP of the African countries is basically unchanged.
As soon as the foriign money influx is spent, the system collapses, since the entire economy is based on
foreign money. Often leads to political crises, coups, etc.
Possible solutions:
- Issuing bonds in the capital market - way to raise money, companies issue bonds that spread
between investors with the promise to repay with an interest rate. In this case a government of a
country issues bonds. In this case the relationship is multilateral and anonymous.
- Bank loan - bilateral contract.
- Raising taxes.
In addition the capital received through bank loan or bonds should be invested into the income generated
activity. Thus, increasing income the government receives more tax money that can be invested into the
infrastructure or another productive activity.
If the capital is not invested into the productive activity, it’s just a flow, ex: distributing food to the poor.
Searching for solutions for people not to count on charity or donors, we should think about how to deliver
tools (assets, equipment) and/or skills (knowledge, education, training) for them to take care of
themselves, to promote self-help. Self-help 90% goes to small entrepreneurs, but not all people are
entrepreneurs. Nevertheless only 10% can go to education and developing skills, that will help to be self
sustainable, to get a salary based job. Yet, microfinance in the vastest majority support small individual
entrepreneurial activity
pf3
pf4
pf5
pf8
pf9

Pré-visualização parcial do texto

Baixe Microfinance for social change e outras Resumos em PDF para Microfinanças, somente na Docsity!

The World Bank target for eradicating poverty by 3% is growth in GDP per capita of 4% every year globally. GDP is related to a profit (not revenue) generated within a nation. Divided per capita is GDP per capita. The higher is the GDP growth the lower is the poverty in the country. In the EU 20 to 25% of people are living at risk of poverty and social exclusion. We do not define the poor by the number of $ per day, but what the person can afford and what choices and opportunities they have. In the EU poverty is defined as 17% below the average income in a national level - relative measure. Absolute measure - in each country Eurostat defines basic needs, if you can not pay it, you are in a ‘severe deprivation”. Roughly 10% of those 25%. Microfinance is the result of the capitalist system, it’s also a part of it, where GDP defines growth. Microfinance supports where the capital is needed. WHY GROWTH IS EVIL? If we talk about growth and numbers and consumption, we only talk about quantity, we are missing quality. If we expect non-stop growth due to consumption, we are consuming useless goods, that if we drop the quality of life might stay the same. Moreover the consumption based economy is dangerous for the planet. Solution: Is there a way to produce GDP without hurting people and the planet? Kate Rowarth produced a framework. We have to choose among businesses which are in between a certain threshold related to hr and ecology. 17/11/ Billions of dollars are spent into intern.cooperation in Africa for nothing. Over the last years the aid grew every year, while the GDP of the African countries is basically unchanged. As soon as the foriign money influx is spent, the system collapses, since the entire economy is based on foreign money. Often leads to political crises, coups, etc. Possible solutions:

  • Issuing bonds in the capital market - way to raise money, companies issue bonds that spread between investors with the promise to repay with an interest rate. In this case a government of a country issues bonds. In this case the relationship is multilateral and anonymous.
  • Bank loan - bilateral contract.
  • Raising taxes. In addition the capital received through bank loan or bonds should be invested into the income generated activity. Thus, increasing income the government receives more tax money that can be invested into the infrastructure or another productive activity. If the capital is not invested into the productive activity, it’s just a flow, ex: distributing food to the poor. Searching for solutions for people not to count on charity or donors, we should think about how to deliver tools (assets, equipment) and/or skills (knowledge, education, training) for them to take care of themselves, to promote self-help. Self-help 90% goes to small entrepreneurs, but not all people are entrepreneurs. Nevertheless only 10% can go to education and developing skills, that will help to be self sustainable, to get a salary based job. Yet, microfinance in the vastest majority support small individual entrepreneurial activity

Vulnerability - the probability to fall below the minimal standard due to external shocks (ex.climate change), not an actual situation like the definition of poverty. Climate change is not included in the poverty definition, but in the vulnerability definition, since it might affect the assets or inemployment of the affected people. On the level of the EU it's the 15% that are living at risk of poverty. In microfinance interventions we are targeting not only poor people, but also vulnerable people. 22/11/ Methodologies for measuring the impact of the intervention: 1st group - RANDOMIZED CONTROL TRIALS (RCT) - experimental People selected for the trial are selected randomly, not chosen on certain characteristics. The group of people is controlled by another group that lives in the same conditions, but they have not been treated. Everything is the same, except our intervention - then you can compare after the intervention. 2nd group - NON RANDOMIZED STUDIES - quasi-experimental

  • There are 2 groups, but there is no assurance that they are exactly the same. In this case they have to control if the characteristics that are not perfectly matching have an impact on the result. 3d - NON-EXPERIMENTAL Interviews, focus-groups, but there is no second group to compare. For policy making it is not a good methodology, but it works to give feedback to stakeholders and donors it might work.YOU CAN ONLY DESCRIBE WHAT HAPPENED TO THOSE PEOPLE BUT NEVER CONCLUDE THE CAUSAL EFFECT. RCT is a relatively new methodology in social sciences, around 20 years back. Yet it has more than 50 years of practice in medicine. In that case there is a 3d group to check if there are no side effects - some get placebo, some don't and we see if there are side effects. RCT in Microfinance is getting more and more to execute since there are basically no places of earth not affected by Microfinance, thus, the second control group is hard to form. Non-mainstream tool for measuring poverty - PPI - Progress Out of Poverty Index, measures the probability to be poor, country specific. Poverty assessment is based on gathering info on the items that describe your household, such as food, asset ownership, job, etc, 10 different items. Poverty assessment is based on the items possessed by a household, country specific questionnaire. MICROFINANCE PROVIDERS 23/11/

In many countries cooperatives should work only with the members, but sometimes they can also attract deposits and lend loans to outsiders. Often the outsiders have other conditions, more costly services, higher interest rates. Other providers:

  1. Savings and credit associations (SACCOs)
  2. NGOs - some have the goal to provide financial services. It is not a cooperative because the members of the organization are in most of the cases not the beneficiaries of the intervention. Exactly to the contrary of the coops they are set to support the outsiders. They can raise funds and provide microcredit or offer saving services.
  3. Money transfer companies - related to remittances. Migrants send money back home through money transfer operators like Western Union. Nowadays the range of companies is extending towards the phone operators. They are part of the microfinance arena since the money they are moving is used in the receiving end for the income generating activities. Regulated Institutions Regulated institutions are mostly banks and also MFi. In the vast majority of cases the authority is the Central Bank. Standard regulation - fill the min. capital requirement to start a microfinance institution. The shareholders (owners) should deposit the min amount of money on the bank account in order to guarantee to afford risks and losses. The amount varies by country regulations. The higher the min requirement, the less will be the number of bank operators in the country, only big ones. Otherwise there can be a lot of small ones. Only banks can receive money (accept deposit) from the general public. This regulation is meant to protect the savings of people. Cooperatives usually can only accept savings from the members even if they lend to outsiders. In informal markets (self help group) everything is based on trust, banks are regulated. Banks ownership: -can be owned by the state - supposed to be an operating tool for implementing strategic policy actions, industry targets (for ex. deliver credits to green enterprises, if there is a green policy in the country).
  • private banks - profit generating only and paying it back to the shareholders
  • bank-cooperative - supposed to support their members, stricter regulations than cooperatives, in terms of minimal capital, supervised by the Central Bank, and provide a full range of services only banks can provide. All cooperatives are supposed to be formed to benefit the members - lower costs, longer period of the loans. Cooperative is here to support commercial inclusion, banks are supposed to generate profit. Microcredit:
  • boost revenues, jobs creation, empowerment - self-confidence
  • risk of overestimating the revenues, as a result - over indebtment Microfinance is not only money but also training - ex. Accounting. Often MFI institutions do not have a capacity to provide training on all the necessary topics. Partnership and networks help. Another solution - form a cooperative among MFIs. Only MFI can provide micro-insurance specifically to farmers, specifically in the climate change era. New area for microfinance is remittances business - channels the capital inflow from the workers outside. MFI are more organized to reach remote areas. 29/11/ Micro Insurance In case of a negative event the insurance must pay, but it is challenging in case of nomad people. Main problems:
  1. Channel - how to connect the client with the insurance company most probably in the city, how to find the client and sign the contract
  • Make an agreement between the insurance company and microfinance institution in the village.
  • Use of mobile, communication through sms, transfer mobile credit to pay for services.
  1. 3d party assessment - how to measure the event, certify that the event happened (it should be the 3d party to avoid the fraude)
  2. Find a way to give the money back from the headquarters to the client affected (often not even having a bank account)
  • Same solution with sms 30/11/ Remittances - cash flow from individual workers abroad to the home country, based on the savings generated abroad. People to people. RELISTEN THE RECORDING 1/12/ Assessing financial needs MF instruments for financial inclusion mentioned before - savings, credit, insurance, mobile banking, etc. How to understand which solution is the best in different cases. FINANCIAL NEED Cases:
  1. Income is growing slowly, but there is a need to boost it, to quiquer achieve a higher level of income.
  2. Income is growing, but is unstable, the need is to stabilize steady growth, to make it more predictable.
  3. Sudden decrease due to a shock, sometimes having the income, the need is to stop the fall, to minimise the losses. Solutions (instruments):
  4. Case 1 - Microcredit (loans) to be invested into profitable activities or assets that will potentially increase the income. It's important also to do market research to assess the demand and learn regulations in order for the business not to fail. Frequency is lower than iDrn savings, you usually do not ask for a loan every month. Checks to be made before taking a new loan:
  • the previous debt (loan is already paid) or
  • the income generating asset is repaying the loan it was bought with. Each asset should pay its own loan, otherwise it's impossible to understand if the asset is profitable. The debt should be sooner or later paid, while the asset remains. Unless you sell it, this is a parachute to get you out of poverty. The end should be the paid debt and the property remains. Spending money on assets should help you to earn more and to pay the loan on the asset.
  1. Case 2 - Savings - personal or group savings to avoid moments when expenses are higher than the income. Usually the amount possible to be saved is pretty low, whie the quequency is often high (weekly, monthly).

Microfinance and climate change MISSED 15MIN Impact into people, society, environment by climate change

  • Water shortages
  • Agriculture - food shortages, land destruction, draught - hunger
  • Natural disasters, rising sea levels - Displaced people, job losses, casualties, asset loss, displaced people
  • Inequality : cc affects people in a different way
  • Women are disproportionately affected due to their occupation traditionally more linkid with land and houses
  • Illnesses
  • Conflicts due to the lack of access to the sacred resources We need to find a solution for climate resilience to cope with these challenges that can prevent the migration to a new place. Solutions/strategies:
  • Adaptation - help to do in a different way what we were used to do
  • Mitigation - reduce the impact into the environment (try to put less pressure on the environment), usually only measure the greenhouse gas emission, but not other types of impact (ex. biodiversity) If we fail in adaptation strategy, the result is migration, which is not internationally recognized as a reason for migration so far. Around 10years back the main discourse was related to mitigation (Green New Deal - 100% mitigation). On the highest level of the most developed countries it’s still the main strategy. In the other countries adaptation is more urgent, but so far there are no policies on the high level to target adaptation. Adaptation To implement the adaptation strategy you need capital again (to pump up water, to secure homes, to change materials, to higher the street levels, etc). Capital providers vary - grants, microfinance institutions. Solution:
  • Switch to something that can grow in the new environment - if the business is profitable microfinanc or banks can finance it, training is also needed to switch to another business, is capital providers do not provide training, they are not the best solution
  • Providing equipment to purify water - but it needs to be sustainable, long term, the typical approach of donation - an asset is provided, but no one is responsible for the maintenance, often there is an ownership issue. Impact-output is not enough, we need outcome - who pays for the operating costs, are there necessary details on the market, etc. To what extent is it better to provide a grant or microfinance option (credit)? There is no good solution. Microfinance is a market based solution, we need to check if there is a demand on the market and if the market will be profitable. Topic ideas: Climate change challenges (case studies in different regions and even villages in the world). Which are the alternatives to cope? How climate change is affecting microfinance institutions?
  • People can no longer repay the loans - loss of capital Surviving strategies for MFIs:
  • Organise trainings for people to help to cope with the climate change effects
  • Insurance, possibly also providing insurance along with the loan
  • Consultancy before delivering the loan
  • To provide the capital to cope with the CC 14/12/ CC is a source of migration, but also conflict, ex. pastoralists against the nomads, for water, etc. Lake Chad: CC - scarce resources - Boko Haram is becoming more popular. The competition is unfair because in the fight for resources some groups have guns, some not. The origin of the migration is CC, but only if there is conflict driven by it people have the right to int.protection. MITIGATION Traditional cooking methods - on the fire outside or inside, burning wood - climate change and breathing bad particles Another option - burn charcoal. In many countries it’s homemade. It has less water, the efficiency is more, it’s pure carbon. You need less coal to get the same amount of heat, but it's more costly, but in the end it is more efficient. More efficient ways:
  1. Use of the stove - all the heat stays inside unlike the open fire, so it is more efficient. If the stove costs 300$ and you pay 50$ for coal every day, but with the stove you will save 70% every month. If you pay 300$+10% interest, it's 330 in total. Paid over 12 months it’s 27 per month. It’s a bit more than 20, but at the end of the payment the asset is yours and it will keep on producing revenues. This is MIcrofinance for CC Mitigation because we are using less energy.
  2. Instead of coal pellets (compressed used biomass) can be used. It’s a recycled organic material and there is no need to cut the trees that help the environment. The idea here is to change the